Sunday, June 12, 2005

Mothering ideology, individualism, and mothers in prison

"I want to hug my kids, tell them good morning or tell them good night, that I love them. My pain is my boys, that's my pain, not being with my boys." - Gail, mother of two


"I'm gonna miss being a mom, I wanted to be a mom, I wanted to be there. I want to see my first grandchild, and I want to watch my daughters grow up, go to school..." - Mary, mother of four


The high standard to which mothers are held exists outside the material reality of our lives

Because mothers are widely believed to play a critical role in the organization of social life, everyone has a stake in how motherhood is defined and evaluated. The American ideology of motherhood is a set of interlocking ideas about what it means to be a mother and to perform mothering. Among these are notions of ideal mothering attitudes and practices, including limitless empathy, complete immersion in the care of children and needy others, and subordination of the mother's own needs and desires to those of others. When we become mothers, we are held (often solely) responsible for the development of our children into healthy, competent, moral citizens and productive workers. When our children do not themselves become ideal members of society, it is assumed that we mothers have failed to live up to our natural responsibilities. Mothers are blamed for everything, from criminal behavior, to mental illness, to father-daughter abuse and incest.

The ideology of motherhood is hegemonic. In other words, those who receive it take it for granted; they understand it as the way things are or should be. The ideal mother is something that women are supposed to naturally become, yet her mothering practices are defined outside the social and material conditions of women's lives. The kind of mother we think we are supposed to be is entirely irrelevant and indifferent to the real world we inhabit. The ideal mother is an arbitrary and oppressive social construction, and its violence is most evident on the bodies and lives of women of color and poor women, and their children.

Individualism creates material conditions that are hostile to good mothering, let alone ideal mothering

Motherhood is but one ideological form among others that work together to shape the context of American women's mothering. The cult of American individualism paradoxically results in social and material conditions that prevent mothering, while at the same time reinforcing the ideology of motherhood. For example, individualism has given rise to the "war on crime" in the past two decades, which has redirected the public discourse away from the correlation between crime rates and social problems like poverty (and the institutions and social policies that cause poverty), and has placed the phenomenon of crime squarely and solely on the shoulders of individuals, leading to a meteoric rise in incarceration rates. This is especially true for women, whose numbers in prison have increased 6.3 times since 1980 (Bureau of Justice, 2002).

Poor women and women of color, and their children are most vulnerable

Poor people are much more likely to go to prison than anyone else, and women are more likely to be poor than men. U.S. public policies, contorted by the interdependent ideologies of individualism and motherhood, perpetuate women's poverty by expecting them to bear most of the costs of child care and social reproduction, and to do so with diminished access to higher education; jobs that pay a living wage; quality daycare; health care; and safe, affordable housing, thanks most recently to so-called welfare reform. Under strict surveillance to successfully meet these hopelessly contradictory ideological expectations, poor women are sanctioned for their failure to become both self-made men and selfless mothers, thus continuing their impoverishment and increasing their risk of incarceration.

Criminal justice brings torturous ideological contradictions into clarity

Women's status as mothers upon whom others are dependent is held irrelevant at almost all stages of the criminal justice process, from arrest to judgment and sentencing to incarceration. This is especially true for women of color, who are more likely to be arrested and indicted than white women, to receive longer sentences than whites, and to serve longer before being paroled. Incarcerated women are physically removed from their children while at the same time, little policy or programming is offered to enable them to care for their vulnerable children left behind. When children of incarcerated women exhibit troublesome behaviors, the most likely causes of their problems -- the collective traumas of a history of poverty, parental substance abuse and mental illness, and family violence and instability; disrupted caregiving; exposure to danger as a result of not having a parent there to protect them; and separation from their primary caregivers -- are not considered. Rather, it is deemed the sole failure of incarcerated women themselves to be good mothers. There is an assumption among practitioners, academics, public policy-makers and in the larger society that incarcerated mothers are simply incompetent to provide adequately for their children. However, in several studies incarcerated women have been found to exhibit appropriate maternal attitudes and behaviors, similar to their non-criminal counterparts.

I did my dissertation research in a women's penitentiary in Texas. Because women comprise a relatively small portion of the total prison population, there are only a few women's prisons in the state. Given that Texas is so large, and that prisons ordinarily are located away from major population centers, it was not uncommon for prisoners to reside four or more hours' drive from their families. For families in poverty--and this was the case for almost every inmate I ever met--these women may have lived on the moon. Many women inmates had never received a visit from their children while in prison; some saw their children once a year. In Texas, prison inmates typically are not allowed to use the telephone so women's only opportunity to communicate with their kids was through the mail. Most inmates are school dropouts, and the average educational achievement level is about 8 - meaning that on average, inmates test as if they have an 8th grade education. Twenty-eight percent are reading below 6th grade level. Their ability to build a meaningful connection with their children by exchanging letters is limited not only by their children's literacy levels, but also their own.

These ideological contradictions are as good as violent attacks on women

In the U.S., we expect mothers to have limitless capacity to care for their children while withholding the material means for them to provide even minimal care. This has grave effects for mothers and children in poverty, especially those who commit crimes and become acquainted with criminal justice. Incarceration brings the problem into stark relief, by simultaneously placing the full responsibility for childrens' upbringing on their mothers, while preventing those mothers from interacting with their children on any kind of regular basis.

The correspondences and contradictions of the ideologies of individualism and motherhood conspire to bring about the separation of mothers in poverty from their children (and the traumas associated with it) while providing rationale for this separation. Only in the realm of ideas do perpetual motion machines exist, to carry out the work of preserving social immobility. This immobility is torture, plain and simple, not only for the women who are separated from their children by time and space, but also for the 1.5 million children in the U.S. who have a parent in prison.

"I didn't get no time with her at all. It was, it was like a void. It was like a gap there, an emptiness." - Grace, who gave birth to her daughter in prison

Some further reading.

15 Comments:

Blogger Boudicca said...

Comment cross-posted from BMT

This is a subject close to my heart. For the last 4 years I have been going into a women's prison to run group work with juveniles and young offenders (that is under 18s and 18-21s).

I can only say what it is like here, in England.
There have been a number of reports showing that prison is not the best solution for most women offenders: they have a different mindset to male offenders and have usually offended for different reasons; yet the number of women in prison is climbing rapidly. They also, as you point out, get punished twice - by the loss of their children as well as by the sentence. Here, over 60% of women prisoners have small children and at any one time there will be 1,000 women prisoners who are pregnant.

I don't know if you have mother and baby units there, but we do here. The existence of mother and baby units is often used by judges as in 'you needn't think I will be soft on you because you are pregnant - there are mother and baby units'. Yet there are only 84 mother and baby spaces(that is individual places) in the whole country. Whether a woman gets a place is largely a lottery, depending on how many other women are giving birth at the time. The granting of places also depends on a woman's offence.

Of the girls I work with, around 20% will be pregnant at any time and a substantial further number will have babies 'outside'. These kids break my heart on a regular basis, but the hardest thing I saw was a girl due to be induced on the saturday of that week: the next Tuesday (i.e. third day after giving birth), I was in again and she walked into the group having just been brought back to the wing. All she had was a polaroid photo of her son and he had been taken out to foster care. As a woman and mother my breasts physically ached in sympathy with her.

The vast majority of women and girls in prison are victims in some way:
>Over half of women in prison report that they have suffered domestic violence and one in three has experienced sexual abuse.
>One in four women in prison have spent time in local authority care as a child.
>Nearly 40 per cent of women in prison leave school before the age of 16 years, almost one in ten were aged 13 or younger.
>Two thirds of women in prison show symptoms of at least one neurotic disorder such as depression, anxiety and phobias. More than half are suffering from a personality disorder. Among the general population less than a fifth of women suffer from these disorders.
> Out of all the women who are sent to prison forty per cent say they have attempted suicide at some time in their life.

I can honestly say that in all the time I have been working with them (running groups twice a week for 4 years), I only ever met 3 girls who were from 'good' homes.

Because most of the women offenders come from poor backgrounds and have low educational achievement they are much more likely to have babies early and 12% of the juveniles in custody are pregnant. Many have had babies at 14/15/16 who are left with relatives or in care when the girls are convicted.

Just about every authority agrees that custodial sentencing is not appropriate for most female offenders yet the numbers of women in custody has trebled in ten years - with the resultant break up of families and damage to children. Around one-third of women prisoners lose their homes, and often their possessions, whilst in prison.

My own view is that it is a terrible waste - a waste of lives and a waste of opportunity to do something about the cycle of poverty/abuse/drugs. If the government were really as forward looking as Blair tries to pretend, use could be made of a woman's time within the criminal justice system to give parenting support, family support and a real chance to break into hopeless lives.

Sexism rears its ugly head here too: girls, especially pretty young girls, are much more likely to get heavier sentences that boys. Societal attitudes are that 'lads will be lads' but girls should be 'nice'. A girl that steps out of that expectation is likely to be punished more for who she is than for the crime she has committed. Around half the girls I have worked with have never had a community sentence nor probation - its custodial for first offences. I could tell some heart breaking stories that would make you weep and rage - but I won't because of the confidentiality and respect I have with them. To give you an idea though, of what these girls are like - just a small example: I was working with a group on self-esteem and self-respect and one of them (17 yo) said "I got self-respect; whenever a bloke hits me I never stay on the floor - I always gets up and faces them"

Please don't think I am a fluffy bleeding-heart do-gooder: I work for a charity, but don't think these girls are helped by sympathy alone. Some of them are very tough indeed, and I have to be very clear about boundaries and about the behaviour I expect. However, I can honestly say I have never met a girl in there I couldn't see some good in, I treat them with respect and they bloom. Many of them have never, in their whole short lives, had someone think them of value.

4:27 PM  
Blogger TeresaInPa said...

Tomato,

This is a subject I am very interested in. At one time I had thought I would get into prison ministries. (I know I know, religion is bad and all that) But I found that prisons and jails in this area are cutting off access to prisoners with the idea that they are there to be punished not comforted or entertained.

10:33 AM  
Blogger Tomato said...

boudicca, women inmates have similar backgrounds of mental illness, drug abuse, domestic violence, previous institutionalization, etc. here in the U.S. Most significant to me for some reason, is the utter poverty from which most women came. I mean, poverty like a middle class American would not imagine. No running water, broken down mobile home, isolated rural areas, or broken down inner city projects. Their real lives were very different from what we might fantasize. For example, the "welfare queen" is a cartoon-like racist, sexist fantasy. African American women I spoke with did not live in conditions of leisure. The women I spoke with were subject to abuse as children and then as adults, worked at jobs that did not pay a living wage, and then succumbed to drugs. The power of drug addiction is incredible! People talk as if you can just walk away from them, but the women I met simply could not. There was no way they chose the lives they had, being in a violent degrading prison while their children were being damaged by foster care or unhealthy extended family situations.

boudicca, I admire you for continuing. I ran a group discussion for a year with women (adults), and conducted other research around that time adding up to a total of 18 months visiting the prison. Frankly, I felt traumatized by the experience, and although I completed the dissertation, it was very difficult to write about the experience since that time, and impossible to return. I am hoping to write some on this blog and hopefully continue to form my thinking around this subject.

12:54 PM  
Blogger Tom Naka said...

Keep it up. I enjoy your nice blog. check out my health net staffing
site. It pretty much covers health net staffing
related stuff.

10:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Essential oils, roots and herbs can be used in a variety of ways to promote healthy living and definition of stress. They are used to create natural remedies for treating ailments common to both people and animals, to add flavor to food, to make perfumes and to create environmentally friendly cleaning products.

You do not have to own a garden to tap into the benefits of plants, roots and herbs. A few herb pots located by a sunny window are enough to get you started. Then, all you need are some essential oils and you are ready to go.

For therapeutic purposes, only the purest oils will do. It is possible to be fooled into thinking that you are purchasing a pure oil. Often, a lesser quality blend of several oils is used to mimic the properties of the pure oil. Blended oils are acceptable for fragrance purposes such as for perfuming a room, but pure oils are a "must" for medicinal purposes.

A reasonable guide to the purity of an essential oil is its price. Pure essential oils are generally more expensive. Common oils such as lavender and geranium are much cheaper than frankincense and carnation oil. It is advisable to become familiar with essential oil prices and then rely on this knowledge when purchasing oils from unfamiliar sources. Keep in-mind that you will generally get what you pay for. A price list from a reputable dealer is a valuable resource when purchasing essentials oils.

Usually, pure essential oils cannot be applied directly to the skin and must be mixed in a base oil to reduce their strength. Base oils such as almond oil or wheatgerm oil are commonly used for this purpose. Base oils are generally derived from seeds, nuts or vegetables and allow you to create essential oil remedies that can be massaged into the skin.

So, what do you need to get started with essential oils and natural remedies?

Without a doubt, Lavender is one of the most useful and desirable oils. Not only does it work wonders on cuts, bruises and burns, it also aids sleep and helps with relaxation.

The Tea Tree and Eucalyptus oils are useful for treating a variety of respiratory ailments. These are excellent for the treatment of colds and coughs. They can be massaged into the chest or burned in an oil burner to help clear the airways and prevent congestion. Tea Tree oil is a natural antiseptic and can be dabbed on cuts, bites and stings. It is often used to treat spots and pimples and when diluted with water, acts as a mouth gargle (keep in-mind it should never be swallowed).

Another basic antiseptic is Geranium oil. With its distinctive perfume and pain relieving properties, it is a necessary inclusion when starting out.

Peppermint oil should also be purchased as it treats digestive complaints and may be used in preparations for freshening breath.

For fragrant perfumes and establishing ambience in a room, buy some Patchouli and Ylang-ylang oils. Often combined in scented candles and air fresheners, a few drops of each in an oil burner creates a wonderfully perfumed home. Orange oil mixed with Cinnamon oil is a lovely winter alternative that evokes seasonal, holiday smells. Besides their perfume qualities, all four of these oils have other properties. Patchouli treats eczema and dandruff. Ylang-ylang is reputed to relieve stress, palpitations and high blood pressure. Orange is used in natural remedies for depression and nervous tension and Cinnamon is excellent for warts and viral infections.

The herbs, Thyme and Rosemary can be grown in pots and used when needed. To create essential oils from herbs, stew some large amounts in pure water, collect the steam and cool it. The oil will rise to the top of the drained water and can be collected with an eyedropper. Alternatively, a "flower still" can be purchased to make the job easier. Thyme and Rosemary are both antiseptics and can be used in skin care preparations. They are also delicious when used in cooking.

Lemon oil and fresh lemons will purify water and, when mixed with honey, are effective remedies for colds and flu. Lemon and white vinegar are highly efficient cleaning agents that can be used for domestic cleaning tasks without damaging the environment. Use white vinegar as a natural disinfectant or mix it with water to clean windows and wooden floors. It is also handy to keep a bottle of white vinegar in your car if you swim in the ocean. It will bring instant relief from jellyfish stings.

Citronella oil is perfect in summer to keep the insects at bay. Another natural repellent is Garlic. Fleas will not bite a dog that has been eating garlic, so a few garlic capsules in the dog food are a cheap solution to your pet's flea problem. A soft collar soaked in Citronella will also do the job.

Garlic also helps to promote a healthy immune system when the weather turns cold and viruses begin to circulate. In fact, most of the oils and herbs listed above are effective in helping to prevent many common winter illnesses.

Whether you are looking for remedies or nature friendly products to use around the house, the oils and herbs suggested above should help get you started. You will be ready to make some healthy changes in your way of life!

definition of stress

9:34 PM  
Anonymous air drying dessicants said...

black mold exposureblack mold symptoms of exposurewrought iron garden gatesiron garden gates find them herefine thin hair hairstylessearch hair styles for fine thin hairnight vision binocularsbuy night vision binocularslipitor reactionslipitor allergic reactionsluxury beach resort in the philippines

afordable beach resorts in the philippineshomeopathy for eczema.baby eczema.save big with great mineral makeup bargainsmineral makeup wholesalersprodam iphone Apple prodam iphone prahacect iphone manualmanual for P 168 iphonefero 52 binocularsnight vision Fero 52 binocularsThe best night vision binoculars here

night vision binoculars bargainsfree photo albums computer programsfree software to make photo albumsfree tax formsprintable tax forms for free craftmatic air bedcraftmatic air bed adjustable info hereboyd air bedboyd night air bed lowest pricefind air beds in wisconsinbest air beds in wisconsincloud air beds

best cloud inflatable air bedssealy air beds portableportables air bedsrv luggage racksaluminum made rv luggage racksair bed raisedbest form raised air bedsaircraft support equipmentsbest support equipments for aircraftsbed air informercialsbest informercials bed airmattress sized air beds

bestair bed mattress antique doorknobsantique doorknob identification tipsdvd player troubleshootingtroubleshooting with the dvd playerflat panel television lcd vs plasmaflat panel lcd television versus plasma pic the bestThe causes of economic recessionwhat are the causes of economic recessionadjustable bed air foam The best bed air foam

hoof prints antique equestrian printsantique hoof prints equestrian printsBuy air bedadjustablebuy the best adjustable air bedsair beds canadian storesCanadian stores for air beds

migraine causemigraine treatments floridaflorida headache clinicdrying dessicantair drying dessicantdessicant air dryerpediatric asthmaasthma specialistasthma children specialistcarpet cleaning dallas txcarpet cleaners dallascarpet cleaning dallas

vero beach vacationvero beach vacationsbeach vacation homes veroms beach vacationsms beach vacationms beach condosmaui beach vacationmaui beach vacationsmaui beach clubbeach vacationsyour beach vacationscheap beach vacations

bob hairstylebob haircutsbob layeredpob hairstylebobbedclassic bobCare for Curly HairTips for Curly Haircurly hair12r 22.5 best pricetires truck bustires 12r 22.5

washington new housenew house houstonnew house san antonionew house venturanew houston house houston house txstains removal dyestains removal clothesstains removalteeth whiteningteeth whiteningbright teeth

jennifer grey nosejennifer nose jobscalebrities nose jobsWomen with Big NosesWomen hairstylesBig Nose Women, hairstyles

2:16 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.blingforfun.com]hip hop jewelry[/url],[url=http://www.blingforfun.com/pendants/cat_9.html]hip hop pendants[/url],hip hop watches,[url=http://blingforfun.com/belts/cat_18.html]bling bling[/url] ,hip hop,[url=http://blingforfun.com/chains/cat_7.html]hip hop chains[/url],hip hop bling,[url=http://blingforfun.com/chains/cat_7.html]iced out chains[/url],[url=http://www.blingforfun.com/chains/cat_7.html]wholesale chains[/url]
hip hop jewelry
wholesale hip hop watches
hip hop rings

10:14 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

minneapolis dating escort [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]horny woman dating[/url] adult sex personals http://loveepicentre.com/ totally free personals

4:41 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

absolute auto audio syracuse [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/car-dvd-player-4inch-tft-lcd-touchscreen--discount-price25.html]car audio for subaru legacy[/url] beststuff fuel car dvd ipod vacation houseboat http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-0-inch-tft-lcd-double-din-dvd-player--discount-price4.html auto dvd player portable
robb report volvo car audio awards [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-inch-tft-touch-sreen-car-dvd-with--discount-price107.html]ipod touch auto audio cable[/url] ipod touch auto audio cable http://www.cardvdplanet.com/buy-cheap-car-dvd1.html auto dvd players
oem car audio ford taurus [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/?action=users]beststuff fuel car dvd ipod vacation houseboat lake[/url] beststuff fuel car dvd ipod vacation houseboat lake powell home http://www.cardvdplanet.com/car-video-dvd-player-single-din-7-inch--discount-price28.html discount auto audio

12:39 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

holistic alternative medicine [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/carafate.htm]carafate[/url] costs of drugs http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/anti-diabetico.htm new pharm medical http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/inderal.htm
breast tenderness and clomid [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/paxil.htm]paxil[/url] medical illustration courses [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/catalogue/u.htm]sugar intake causes heart disease and obesity[/url]

6:45 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

dvs shoes http://topcitystyle.com/prada-casual-shirts-brand10.html soda shoes [url=http://topcitystyle.com/lilac-t-shirts-for-men-color128.html]rocket dog shoes[/url] fifth avenue fashion
http://topcitystyle.com/m-tank-tops-size5.html bedding and ralph lauren [url=http://topcitystyle.com/white-grey-men-color26.html]spary painted shoes[/url]

3:37 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

average cost of a movie ticket [url=http://full-length-movies.com/dvd-quality-movie-mortadelo-y-filemon-mision-salvar-la-tierra/13919database/]Mortadelo Y Filemon Mision Salvar La Tierra[/url] anime porn movie [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-no-maps-for-these-territories/15675database/]No Maps for These Territories[/url]
cinderella movie script [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-jumper/1147database/]Jumper[/url] primevil movie true story behind [url=http://full-length-movies.com/dvd-quality-movie-the-signal/6970database/]The Signal[/url]
pictures of brooke shields from the movie pretty baby [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-the-mist/7868database/]The Mist[/url] anime bento karas the prophecy movie trailer [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-born-yesterday/10580database/]Born Yesterday[/url]
parenthood movie and lyrics to song diahrea [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-el-arcangel/13819database/]El Arcangel[/url] questions over matilda movie [url=http://full-length-movies.com/dvd-quality-movie------------------------------dvd-rmvb.---------/20890database/]????????»???(»?±¬???¤¶????¬)(DVD-RMVB.???????»)[/url]

9:56 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

clothes for thin people http://luxefashion.us/turquoise-white-shirts-color98.html old fashion candy [url=http://luxefashion.us/lavender-men-color69.html]puma childrens shoes home[/url] old easy spirit pattern name shoes
http://luxefashion.us/45-shoes-size51.html wholesale designer handbags [url=http://luxefashion.us/grey-pink-leather-bags-tote-purses-color129.html]womens discounted athletic shoes[/url]

3:17 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

free dad daughter movie clips [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_bloodrayne/]bloodrayne[/url] spongebob the movie xbox game http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_ruckus/ captain planet movie
movie downloads a bugs life [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_v_i_warshawski/]v i warshawski[/url] homemade movie streams http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_run_for_the_money/ hindi movie reviews
will smith future movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_walker/]the walker[/url] spawn 2 the movie
rv movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_mickey_donald_goofy_the_three_musketeers/]mickey donald goofy the three musketeers[/url] the movie scene video store florida http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_perfumed_garden/ windows movie maker pan effects
cast for fox dragonball the movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_frozen_river/]frozen river[/url] pokemon movie download http://moviestrawberry.com/hqmoviesbygenres/download-genre_action-movies/?page=34 molokai movie

10:33 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

movie releases elizabeth [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_donalds_camera/]donalds camera[/url] the princess bride movie photos http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_mortal_passions/ watch the movie prime for free
american movie weekend box office [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_seance_on_a_wet_afternoon/]seance on a wet afternoon[/url] movie clips of pamela anderson http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_red_doors/ femdom handjob free movie
fre bdsm movie clips [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_nurse_jackie/]nurse jackie[/url] the oppsol movie
movie grille in bedford texas [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_practical_magic/]practical magic[/url] movie 1970s fantastic voyage http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_saturday_night_fever/ movie magnolia
apple movie traillers [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_i_paladini_storia_d_armi_e_d_amori/]i paladini storia d armi e d amori[/url] color photos edith head movie costume designs http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_bourne_identity/ harry potter and the order of the phoenix movie online

12:23 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home